[Game #2] Kanes Wrath vs Tiberian Dawn

[CyborgBanana]

TD, it was the game that started the franchise! Also, it's more enjoyable, but KW I admit is very good aswell.

[RedAlert2008]

TD, was the beginning, and where i started

[stephanovich]

Voted TD. Never really gave KW a chance because of all the problems when it was released and I still love playing TD.

[Van4o]

C&C3 in general is a good game, but destroyed the lore, which C&C, Tiberian Sun, Firestorm and even Renegade helped build.

In my view, C&C3 is a perfect example of what not to do when it comes to continuing a franchise. For me the game was full of bad decisions and continuity holes story-wise, so Kane's Wrath felt like it was thrown in to patch-up the situation by introducing new units and expanding "lore", which C&C3 introduced.
When playing the campaign of both the original and the expansion, the game felt like there was a fight between the story and design departments in EALA. The "story" was about the future, yet the game felt like it was a reboot of the franchise, rather than a sequel. All of that, coupled with symetrical maps and fast-pased gameplay ruined the feel of the older C&Cs. It was a *good* game, but C&C is better.

[1deano1]

Kane's Wrath for me. Loved the sub factions and the general gameplay was very good as well.

[Noodlesocks]

I really like TD. Was the first RTS I ever played and C&C 3 did screw the story up a bit but the gameplay feels really smooth and I the graphics are still pretty nice for the setting and the units and voices and stuff is all pretty cool in KW

[Reno]

Voted KW, but I haven't played TD in so long so my decision was based on a hazy memory. I hope if I play it again I won't find I regret my decision lol.

[Banshee]

TD was very innovative when it was released and, if C&C become a huge and successful franchise, it was certainly thanks to TD. I still prefer TD's campaign than Kane's Wrath. So, my vote goes to TD.

[Commander_McNash]

KW, sure TD is the beginning and deserves great honour, but for me KW was the last truely epic C&C capable to have both awesome graphics, variety of gameplay and a really catching story which you can take seriously.

[D3preda7ion]

wow wow... they just had to make such hard questions? on one hand KW can be argued as the most "C&C" package, but TD is a classic!